Agora, Academy, and the Conduct of Philosophy by Debra Nails

By Debra Nails

Agora, Academy, and the behavior of Philosophy deals tremendous cautious and special criticisms of a few of the main very important assumptions students have dropped at endure in starting the strategy of (Platonic) interpretation. It is going directly to provide a brand new strategy to staff the dialogues, in keeping with vital evidence within the lives and philosophical practices of Socrates - the most speaker in so much of Plato's dialogues - and of Plato himself. each side of Debra Nails's arguments deserve shut consciousness: the unfavourable aspect, which exposes loads of range in a box that regularly claims to have accomplished a consensus; and the optimistic part, which insists that we needs to attend to what we all know of those philosophers' lives and practices, if we're to make a significant try to comprehend why Plato wrote the way in which he did, and why his writings appear to depict diverse philosophies or even assorted methods to philosophizing.
From the Preface by means of Nicholas D. Smith.

Show description

Read Online or Download Agora, Academy, and the Conduct of Philosophy PDF

Similar greek & roman books

Socratic Presence. A Study of the Sources

The critical target of this publication is a composite biographical and philosophical portrait of Socrates, during which the first assets and the entire significant secondary assets are tested and brought under consideration, with ample quotations and references, and within which the end result of contemporary Socratic scholarship are judiciously pronounced and assessed.

Plato's Thought in the Making

The philosophy of Plato embraces even more than metaphysics; his basic difficulty was once with the query of ways guy may still behavior himself as he ought, and metaphysics used to be studied for the sake of this. but for many readers 'Plato' indicates the speculation of rules, most likely disguised at the back of a few such renowned suggestion as 'platonic' love.

The Other Plato: The Tübingen Interpretation of Plato’s Inner-Academic Teachings

Supplying a provocative replacement to the dominant methods of Plato scholarship, the Tübingen college means that the dialogues don't inform the complete tale of Plato’s philosophical teachings. Texts and fragments by means of his scholars and their followers—most famously Aristotle’s Physics—point to an “unwritten doctrine” articulated by means of Plato on the Academy.

Passions and persuasion in Aristotle's rhetoric

For Aristotle, arousing the passions of others can quantity to giving them right grounds for conviction. On that foundation a ability in doing so may be whatever useful, a suitable constituent of the type of services in rhetoric that merits to be cultivated and given expression in a well-organised country.

Extra info for Agora, Academy, and the Conduct of Philosophy

Sample text

Two pages after the preceding, and having provided his influential Cambridge Companion to Plato with an uncritical chronological table of the composition of the dialogues (xii), Kraut advocates beginning from the assumption that Plato's views are presented by his principal interlocutor in order that "we need make no hazardous assumptions about why he wrote, and why he wrote in dialogue form" (29). An inauspicious beginning, in my view, and not isolated. Later, Kraut remarks that Tigerstedt's (1977) "overview is marred, in my opinion, by his assumption that because of internal conflicts in every dialogue we cannot take Socrates to be a mouthpiece for Plato's views" (49 n.

Why, qua philosophers, we even care about issues in the history of ideas I will take up again in the next chapter. Meanwhile, suffice it to say that, qua philosophers, we ought at least to be aware of, but preferably ought to be able to defend, the premises we deploy in our arguments. Of the four premises of the two positions I have just outlined, I cannot satisfactorily defend a single one. Nor do I find others' defenses of them adequate; in other words, I do not myself hold any of those premises, and I am suspicious of research that proceeds on the basis of any of them.

The problem with the third premise is also related to the Crito: Socrates says in the Apology that he will disobey the jury if it tells him to stop conducting philosophy, but says in the Crito that he must obey the laws of Athens. Although various resolutions to this philosophical discrepancy have been offered in the literature, the fact that resolutions are needed makes me suspicious of the claim that there is special philosophical affinity between the two works. Brickhouse and Smith make a good case for the relative accuracy of the Apology-as good a case as has been made.

Download PDF sample

Agora, Academy, and the Conduct of Philosophy by Debra Nails
Rated 4.45 of 5 – based on 27 votes